McShay: Bengals Face Tough Call as Top Corners May Vanish at 10

Imago
Rueben Bain Jr: CREDIT: IMAGO / ZUMA Press Wire ,Jermod McCoy: CREDIT: IMAGO / ZUMA Press Wire Mansoor Delane: CREDIT: IMAGO / ZUMA Press Wire
The Cincinnati Bengals head into the 2026 draft looking to fix the leaks on their defense. But holding the No. 10 pick, their plan might fail. If early picks shift, their top targets may not be there when they are on the clock. An NFL analyst stirred the pot a little more.
Todd McShay shared his take on The McShay Show, linking directly to Cincinnati’s situation. The Bengals are believed to be choosing between two priorities. Bolstering their pass rush with Rueben Bain Jr. or upgrading their secondary with a top cornerback like Jermod McCoy or Mansoor Delane.
“Now it becomes interesting. If Bain’s sitting there at 10, is that their edge? And it certainly could be. But they also could take the other corner,” McShay said.
That puts pressure on teams picking in the top 10, including the Bengals
“I think Miami at 11 could take a corner. I know Dallas would love to have one, but I don’t think either of them gets to 12," McShay said. "I actually don’t know that either of them gets to 11.”
They added help on the defensive line and at safety in free agency, but the cornerback room did not get the same attention. Right now, DJ Turner II and Dax Hill are expected to start, but both are in contract years. That makes this position one to watch closely in the draft.
In that way, the biggest concern for the Bengals is the cornerback market drying up almost instantly. Cincinnati will be chased by the Miami Dolphins and Dallas Cowboys, as McCoy and Delane might become unavailable within the next couple of picks.
That's where the dilemma sets in. If the Cincinnati Bengals view Bain as their top defensive priority, they could lean toward selecting him at No. 10. However, if they do so, they might miss out on the elite tier of cornerbacks.
Alternatively, if they see a sharp drop-off at the corner, they may feel compelled to take McCoy or Delane right away, even if Bain ranks higher on their overall board. Now that's indeed a tough call for the Bengals.
Rueben Bain Jr.'s trait can be a deciding factor for the Cincinnati Bengals in the draft
Cincinnati's target, Bain Jr., has played at a level that puts him in first-round talks, but one factor might leave teams in two minds. His arm length measured just under 31 inches at the NFL Combine, which is shorter than what teams usually want for edge rushers.
That number matters more than it looks. In recent years, players with shorter arms have either gone late or not been picked high at all. That makes teams pause before taking someone like Bain in the top 10.
The reason? Edge rushers use their arms to keep blockers away, control the line, and reach the quarterback. With shorter arms, it can get harder to win those battles, especially in the NFL, where linemen are stronger and quicker.
Still, Bain’s performance cannot be ignored. In the 2025 season, he recorded 30 solo tackles and 9.5 sacks, along with one interception across 16 games. That shows he can still make plays despite that limitation, which is why some teams may still rate him highly.
Which way do you think the Bengals will head? Drop your thoughts.
Find more news at Cincinnati Bengals Community.
Written by
Anjali Thakur
Edited by
Soheli Tarafdar