Joe Burrow thrown out of top 5 QBs as ex-Super Bowl champion drops bold take

Icon Sportswire
CINCINNATI, OH - JANUARY 04: Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow 9 looks at the scorebord during the game against the Cleveland Browns and the Cincinnati Bengals on January 4, 2026, at Paycor Stadium in Cincinnati, OH. Photo by Ian Johnson/Icon Sportswire NFL, American Football Herren, USA JAN 04 Browns at Bengals EDITORIAL USE ONLY Icon260104150
Former NFL defensive end and Super Bowl XLVI champion Chris Canty has made a bold take about Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow, throwing him out of the top five quarterbacks altogether after Burrow was ranked No. 4 in ESPN's 2026 quarterback survey.
"First of all, in two of the last three years, Joe Burrow has missed two months of the season, and it just so happens to coincide with the Cincinnati Bengals being on the outside looking into the postseason in three straight years. I'm tired of all of the Joe Burrow sycophants," Canty said on ESPN's First Take.
Canty's argument rests on two specific pillars. First, availability: Joe Burrow struggled with a wrist injury in 2023 and a severe turf toe injury in 2025, limiting him to just 10 games and eight games respectively.

Second, results: the Bengals have missed the playoffs for three straight seasons, from 2023 to 2025, though Burrow was productive in the playoffs when he was not injured.
"Matter of fact, the last time they were in the postseason was 2022, and this dude, going into year seven, we're talking about him only being in the postseason twice. I don't understand how we're giving Joe Burrow all of these kudos," Canty said on ESPN's First Take. "Joe Burrow is not a top five quarterback in our league."
The counter-argument is hard to ignore because Burrow, in his full 17-game 2024 season, led the NFL in completions, racking up 4,918 passing yards and 43 passing TDs to 9 interceptions. Also, he is the only active AFC QB who has beaten the Patrick Mahomes Kansas City Chiefs in the playoffs.
Bengals fans may need to think on the question more given Burrow's potential, and for Canty, it makes sense that Burrow impacts results more than Burrow's own production, but of course results can be impacted by injury and a quarterback's availability.
The stakes for Cincinnati in 2026 are higher than just a single season for one reason, and that reason is ceiling.
Dan Graziano warns Bengals face Joe Burrow questions if they miss 2026 playoffs
The Bengals wanted to show Burrow the team means business and intends to compete for championships during Burrow's prime and signed Jonathan Allen, Boye Mafe, and Bryan Cook in free agency before trading for Dexter Lawrence II.
ESPN's Dan Graziano explained what is at stake with another year of missed playoffs.
"If they miss the playoffs again, then that would be, we talked about how they're the only team that didn't change head coaches," Graziano said on the July 21 edition of Get Up. "That could certainly be on the table. And the chatter about whether or not Joe Burrow should leave Cincinnati. That's going to be a big topic next offseason."
After making the playoffs three years in a row and getting knocked out of the playoffs, the pressure on both sides has never been higher.
Where does Joe Burrow rank on your top 5 QBs list right now? Let us know in the comments!
Read more at the Cincinnati Bengals Community!
Written by

Abhay Bharti
Edited by

Shubhi Rathore