Deshaun Watson unlikely to "survive an entire season" as injury concerns emerge amid QB battle, analyst claims

Imago
Deshaun Watson and Shedeur Sanders/Images via Imago
Young QBs Shedeur Sanders and Dillon Gabriel continue to push for opportunities in the Cleveland Browns' quarterback competition, while Deshaun Watson's health remains under the spotlight.
NFL analyst Adam "the Bull" Gerstenhaber shared a blunt statement on the Ultimate Cleveland Sports Show. As the Browns evaluate their QB options, the discussion has now shifted to whether Watson's body can hold up throughout the season.
"There's not a chance in hell this guy is going to be healthy enough to survive an entire season, rather less maybe one or two games of an NFL season," Adam the Bull said on July 9. "There's no benefit to playing Deshaun Watson if he can't stay healthy."

Imago
Deshaun Watson. Image Credits: Mark Goldman/Imago
Adam argued on the Ultimate Cleveland Sports Show that Watson's injury history makes it too risky to build the offense around him. It would be better for the Browns to consider younger QBs if he can't be consistently on the field.
Watson suffered a season-ending Achilles injury in 2024 before fracturing the tendon during his recovery, which added to previous shoulder issues that also limited his availability.
Even after returning to offseason workouts and taking first-team reps, his medical history raises concerns. Despite those concerns, Watson has maintained that his only goal is to stay fully healthy and earn the Browns' starting role.
Cleveland has allowed him to compete, but the franchise has also added young QBs to increase competition and prepare for scenarios if injuries become a major issue again.
The Browns have yet to announce the starting QB. But the distribution of reps during minicamp suggests that the competition may be shifting in Shedeur Sanders' favor.
Shedeur Sanders' first-team reps create doubts on Deshaun Watson's hold on the QB1 job
The Browns' beat reporter, Mary Kay Cabot, pointed to one notable action that caught her attention during Cleveland's offseason minicamp.
“I thought it was very significant that when we showed up for the very first day of mandatory minicamp, the player taking most of the first-team reps on that day, on the first day of mandatory minicamp, was Shedeur Sanders, I just thought that was significant,” Mary Kay Cabot said via Touchdown Wire on July 9.
Cabot's observation has added momentum to the belief that Sanders is making a strong case to overtake Watson in the race for QB1.
While one practice does not determine the depth chart, first-team reps give insights into the coaching staff's evaluation process as training camp approaches.
What are your views on Shedeur Sanders taking over Watson as QB1? Let us know in the comments!
Read more at the Cincinnati Bengals Community!
Written by

Hetal Moleshri
Edited by
Arundhoti Palit