Bengals Issued "Automatic Backfire" Warning Over $28M Move

Icon Sportswire
EAST RUTHERFORD, NJ - SEPTEMBER 28: Dexter Lawrence 97 of the New York Giants intercepts a pass and runs toward the endzone during the first quarter of the game against the Los Angeles Chargers on September 28, 2025 at MetLife Stadium in East Rutherford, New Jersey. Photo by Rich Graessle/Icon Sportswire NFL, American Football Herren, USA SEP 28 Chargers at Giants EDITORIAL USE ONLY Icon25092818573
The Cincinnati Bengals' trade for Dexter Lawrence has sparked debate across the league, mostly because of the price they paid to get it done. Moving the 10th overall pick was a significant decision, and it immediately put the spotlight on how the deal could play out over time.
Lawrence also comes with the usual talking points for a player at his stage, age, workload over the years, and whether his production holds steady going forward. That's where Brad Gagnon of Bleacher Report stepped in with a more cautious read on the move.
"Lawrence will turn 29 this season, and the big guy might be beyond his prime," Gagnon wrote on Monday. "His raw and rate-based numbers have dropped off the last couple of seasons, and he'll cost about $70 million over the next three years. And if he isn't, this is an automatic backfire."
Lawrence’s sack production dropped dramatically, from 9.0 in 12 games (2024) to just 0.5 sacks in a full 17-game season (2025).
With Lawrence carrying a $28 million annual salary, the Bengals could be investing close to $70 million in him over the next three years.

Icon Sportswire
EAST RUTHERFORD, NJ - SEPTEMBER 28: Dexter Lawrence 97 of the New York Giants intercepts a pass and runs toward the endzone during the first quarter of the game against the Los Angeles Chargers on September 28, 2025 at MetLife Stadium in East Rutherford, New Jersey. Photo by Rich Graessle/Icon Sportswire NFL, American Football Herren, USA SEP 28 Chargers at Giants EDITORIAL USE ONLY Icon25092818574
The Bengals, however, are expecting that a change of scenery and a stronger supporting cast can help Lawrence return to his best form. The move was made with the goal of upgrading a defense that needed more consistency and experience up front.
For now, it's one of those deals that will be judged over time, depending on how it fits into the bigger picture for the Bengals moving forward.
Bengals Veteran Explains Why Dexter Lawrence Is Different
The Cincinnati Bengals made a major investment in Dexter Lawrence this offseason, but his impact is already being felt long before he takes a regular-season snap for the team.
Speaking on First Word With James Rapien, Bengals center Ted Karras explained why Lawrence has been one of the toughest defensive linemen to face during his career and what his arrival means for Cincinnati's defense.
"When you sign a guy like Dexter Lawrence, everyone on defense automatically gets better. Because there's now the singular guy that people are gonna have to account for," Karras said on Monday.
Lawrence’s ability to command extra attention up front is one of the biggest reasons Cincinnati targeted him. Karras believes that impact extends beyond Lawrence's individual production.
"He's the pinnacle of our defense, and [he] changes the dynamic of game planning for the Cincinnati Bengals," Karras said on Monday.
For the Bengals' defense looking to take a step forward in 2026, Lawrence's presence alone could force the opponents' offense to rethink how they take on the Cincinnati Bengals.
What are your thoughts about this trade?
Read more at the Cincinnati Bengals Community!
Written by

Debanjali Rakshit
Edited by
Zaid Quraishi