Aaron Rodgers hit with damning stat as "Is he even bringing anything?" question emerges

Zuma
Nov 30, 2025: Aaron Rodgers 8 during the Pittsburgh Steelers vs Buffalo Bills game in Pittsburgh, PA. /CSM Pittsburgh USA - ZUMAcp5_ 20251130_faf_cp5_094 Copyright: xJasonxPohuskix
When the Pittsburgh Steelers hired head coach Mike McCarthy to replace Mike Tomlin, everyone expected a major structural overhaul. Though now reunited with his former Super Bowl-winning coach, his output, given his oldest QB in the league tag, is being questioned.
While Rodgers gave Pittsburgh its best quarterback play in years last season, critics are heavily questioning if the 42-year-old can do it again. On an episode of The Mic with Steve Palazzolo & Sam Monson podcast, analyst Sam Monson openly doubted his remaining value.
“Is Rodgers even bringing anything to the table anymore?... The guy averaged like 6.5 yards per attempt last season. His PFF grade was entirely mid. He didn't look that great.” Sam noted of Rodgers' performance last season. “ If you want to use really quick ESPN's QBR, his last three starting seasons, he's been in the bottom five to seven, right?”

Imagn
Aaron Rodgers. Image Credits: Berry Reeger/Imagn
As Monson pointed out, Rodgers received a 68.7 PFF grade last year, ranking him 29th among 43 quarterbacks. The Super Bowl-winning quarterback specifically averaged 6.7 yards per attempt.
Monson highlighted Rodgers' declining stats during The Mic with Steve Palazzolo & Sam Monson podcast, across his last three starting seasons
2022 (Packers): Started all 17 games. He threw for 3,695 yards, 26 touchdowns, and 12 interceptions, finishing with a 91.1 passer rating.
2024 (Jets): Started all 17 games. He threw for 3,897 yards, 28 touchdowns, and 11 interceptions, finishing with a 90.5 rating.
2025 (Steelers): Started 16 games. He threw for 3,322 yards, 24 touchdowns, and 7 interceptions, finishing with a 94.8 rating.
Monson argues that Aaron Rodgers is no longer a game-changer.
“His touchdown interception ratio at his peak was the most ridiculous thing you've ever seen in your life, utterly bad numbers, 50-something touchdowns, five interceptions type of deal.”
While Rodgers used to post historic numbers, his scoring is way down, and his turnovers are up.
“Now he's at 24 and 8, 28 and 11, right? Even that has taken a massive swing in the wrong direction, and every other number you can look at is down as well.”
The Steelers team has built its entire 2026 offseason around the hope that in his final year, Rodgers finds his MVP-winning form again.
However, given his massive decline, analysts believe it's doubtful that Rodgers can even help the team improve the score they have now.
NFL analyst skeptical of Rodgers' presence with the Steelers
The Pittsburgh Steelers spent a lot of time and effort rebuilding their team this offseason, but some experts are still not convinced it will work.
NFL analyst Nate Tice believes the main issue is the quarterback, Aaron Rodgers. During an episode of the NFL Daily podcast, Tice explained his doubts by saying:
"It's the quarterback, that's what's holding me back," Tice added. "I think most people don't think that's the thing that's limiting it."
Tice worries about Rodgers turning 43 years old this season. He also has a complicated history with his coach, Mike McCarthy, from their past days playing together in Green Bay, even though they speak very highly of each other now.
However, older quarterbacks can be unpredictable. While older players can suddenly lose their edge, Rodgers showed last season that he can still throw the football incredibly well.
For Tice, Rodgers is the biggest question mark holding the team back, or he could easily be the exact reason the Steelers find success.
Read more at the Cincinnati Bengals Community!
Written by

Aaindri Thakuri
Edited by

Aadesh Dhote